Cloth Diaper Statistics

 

 


Scroll over the “Stats” option on the navigation bar at the top of this site to get directly to a particular diaper type.

Tables are sorted by diaper type and there are two tables per diaper type (Baby Type and Diaper Features).

Scores are based on averages and I converted the averages to percentages (so if they rated on a scale of 1 to 5, I calculated the average and divided it by 5 to turn it into a percentage). The best way to look at these numbers is to COMPARE them with one another. Select the diamond next to the column title you are interested in and it will sort the numbers in that category from low to high, click it again and see numbers from high to low. This is a great way to compare how the diapers worked since it ranks them in that category. And if looking at just numbers is confusing, I provide summaries of the results in my reviews here.

All in One Cloth Diapers

Diaper (# responses)
PriceAll BabiesHeavy WetterChunkyChunky ThighsSkinnySkinny ThighsRash ProneTall
Blueberry Basix AIO (21)

Click here to buy
$17.95-$21.95
74%
74%
76%
77%
N/A
N/A
79%
67%
Blueberry Simplex (One Size) (formerly Swaddlebees) (39)

Click here to buy


$25.95
79%
79%
84%
82%
83%
79%
78%
81%
Bottombumpers Side Snapping AIO - One Size (20)

Click here to buy
$20.95-$22.95
75%
73%
74%
75%
74%
74%
78%
72%
Bottombumpers Side Snapping (Sized) (22)

Click here to buy
$18.95-$20.95
72%
73%
69%
66%
76%
79%
77%
71%
bumGenius AIO (sized) (79)
DISCONTINUED

N/A
77%
76%
75%
74%
79%
78%
77%
75%
bumGenius Elemental AIO (old version - rolled elastic) (117)

Click here to buy


N/A
76%
76%
71%
74%
77%
79%
76%
73%
bumGenius Freetime AIO (113)

Click here to buy
$19.95
80%
80%
81%
81%
78%
78%
81%
78%
Chelory AIO
Click here to buy
$30-$34.95
86%
87%
84%
85%
86%
88%
87%
89%
GroVia AIO (117)

Click here to buy
$23.95
71%
72%
65%
68%
74%
75%
75%
68%
GroVia Newborn AIO (38)

Click here to buy
$14.95
71%
64%
66%
65%
71%
71%
71%
71%
Itti Bitti D'Lish AIO (24)

Click here to buy
$18.95
78%
78%
74%
77%
79%
81%
78%
78%
Itti Bitti Tutto (51)
Click here to buy
$36.71
67%
62%
64%
66%
69%
71%
67%
68%
Ones & Twos (22)

Click here to buy
$16.95
63%
62%
N/A
69%
63%
63%
60%
66%
Ragababe Easy AIO (31)

Click here to buy
$27.95-$29.95
88%
87%
95%
92%
86%
85%
88%
85%
Rumparooz Lil Joey (39)

Click here to buy

$14.99 each (they are generally sold in a two pack for $29.97)
77%
73%
77%
83%
69%
69%
70%
70%
Thirsties Duo AIO (129)

Click here to buy
$15.75-$16.75
74%
74%
74%
72%
77%
76%
74%
72%
Diaper (# responses)
Price
Total Score
Absorbency
Fit on Baby
Worth the Price
Trim on Baby
Liked by Skeptics
Night (as is)
Night (not as purchased)
Would Recommend
Blueberry Basix AIO (21)
Click here to buy
$17.95-$21.95
74%
74%
90%
83%
86%
79%
45%
58%
83%
Blueberry Simplex 2.0 (sized) (formerly Swaddlebees) (45)
Click here to buy
79%
86%
91%
85%
93%
87%
48%
60%
91%
Blueberry Simplex (One Size) (formerly Swaddlebees) (39)
Click here to buy
$20.95-$22.95
73%
86%
85%
83%
83%
80%
59%
75%
90%
Bottombumpers Side Snapping AIO - One Size (20)
Click here to buy
$20.95-$22.95
75%
85%
91%
84%
88%
79%
47%
51%
88%
Bottombumpers Side Snapping (Sized) (22)
Click here to buy
$18.95-$20.95
72%
79%
91%
85%
97%
81%
35%
39%
85%
bumGenius AIO (sized) (93)
DISCONTINUED
N/A
78%
75%
85%
84%
84%
88%
57%
69%
87%
bumGenius Elemental AIO (Old version - Rolled elastic) (143)
Click here to buy
N/A
76%
87%
84%
77%
81%
82%
56%
62%
85%
bumGenius Freetime AIO (140)
Click here to buy
$19.95
80%
89%
85%
83%
76%
84%
65%
76%
87%
Chelory AIO (32)

Click here to buy
$30-$34.95
86%
96%
88%
85%
78%
90%
77%
86%
90%
GroVia AIO (117)
Click here to buy
$23.95
71%
79%
82%
75%
94%
73%
44%
51%
77%
GroVia Newborn AIO (38)
Click here to buy
$14.95
71%
76%
79%
70%
84%
74%
55%
57%
75%
Itti Bitti D'Lish AIO (24)
Click here to buy
$18.95
78%
85%
83%
78%
87%
85%
63%
67%
86%
Itti Bitti Tutto (51)
Click here to buy
$36.71
67%
82%
67%
66%
75%
67%
55%
59%
67%
Ones & Twos (22)
Click here to buy
$16.95
63%
58%
79%
65%
78%
70%
42%
47%
60%
Ragababe Easy AIO (31)
Click here to buy
$27.95-$29.95
88%
94%
94%
86%
94%
94%%
71%
81%
95%
Rumparooz Lil Joey (36)
Click here to buy
$14.99 each (they are generally sold in a two pack for $29.97)
72%
77%
83%
70%
77%
78%
58%
59%
75%
Thirsties Duo AIO (129)
Click here to buy
$15.75-$16.75
74%
77%
83%
85%
81%
81%
47%
66%
82%

All in Two Cloth Diapers

Diaper (# responses)
Everyone
Heavy Wetter
Chunky
Chunky Thighs
Skinny
Skinny Thighs
Applecheeks (101)
Click here to buy
85%
Photobucket
85%
82%
86%
85%
82%
Best Bottom (106)
Click here to buy
82%
83%
85%
81%
83%
83%
Flip Hybrid System (106)
Click here to buy
78%
79%
80%
79%
77%
78%
gDiaper (109)
Click here to buy
64%
63%
62%
64%
67%
68%
Green Line Diapers (26)
Click here to buy
87%
Photobucket
89%
84%
84%
85%
89%
GroVia All in Two (116)
Click here to buy
78%
74%
76%
75%
75%
76%
Softbums Echo (60)
Click here to buy
83%
84%
88%
86%
85%
86%
Softbums Omni (49)
Click here to buy
84%
82%
83%
83%
77%
80%
Diaper (# responses)
Total
Score
Absor-
bent
Fit on Baby
Worth
the
Price
Trim
on
Baby
Liked
by
Skeptics
Night (as
purchased)
Night (not as is)
Would
Recom-
mend
Applecheeks (101)
Click here to buy
85%
Photobucket
90%
90%
86%
87%
87%
64%
81%
92%
Best Bottom (106)
Click here to buy
82%
88%
84%
89%
85%
84%
57%
80%
88%
Flip Hybrid System (106)
Click here to buy
78%
84%
82%
86%
80%
80%
50%
50%
73%
gDiaper (109)
Click here to buy
64%
69%
74%
65%
88%
61%
42%
56%
62%
Green Line Diapers (26)
Click here to buy
87% Photobucket
93%
86%
89%
93%
85%
74%
78%
92%
GroVia All in Two (116)
Click here to buy
78%
81%
87%
79%
81%
82%
49%
65%
85%
Ragababe Organic 2-Step (24)
Click here to buy
85%
Photobucket
88%
91%
81%
88%
91%
61%
83%
93%
Softbums Echo (60)
Click here to buy
83 %
89%
93%
87%
87%
87%
61%
70%
90%
Softbums Omni (49)
Click here to buy
84%
90%
89%
86%
76%
87%
66%
80%
90%

Cloth Diaper Accessories

Accessory (# responses)
Total
Worth the Price
Ease of Use
Would Recommend
Boingo Diaper Fastener (43)
83%
85%
83%
80%
bumGenius diaper sprayer (58)

Click here to buy
86%
Photobucket
81%
90%
87%
CJs BUTTer (120)

Click here to buy
90%
Photobucket
86%
93%
90%
Grandma El's (22)

Click here to buy
87%
88%
91%
82%
Snappi (94)

Click here to buy
91%
Photobucket
91%
91%
92%

Cloth Diaper Covers

Diaper (# responses)
Everyone
Heavy Wetter
Chunky
Chunky Thighs
Skinny
Skinny Thighs
Rash Prone
Tall
Bummis Super Brite (54)
Click here to buy
82%
77%
84%
81%
80%
82%
82%
81%
Econobum (67)
Click here to buy
79%
77%
84%
79%
80%
75%
74%
77%
Flip (120)
Click here to buy
86%
Photobucket
87%
88%
87%
85%
83%
85%
85%
GroVia Shell (32)
Click here to buy
86%
87%
93%
91%
80%
82%
91%
90%
Rumparooz One Size Cover (21)
Click here to buy
80%
83%
78%
84%
83%
79%
79%
80%
Thirsties Duo Wrap (165)
Click here to buy
88%
Photobucket
87%
89%
88%
88%
88%
87%
86%
Thirsties Sized Covers (60)
Click here to buy
87%
Photobucket
84%
89%
87%
86%
85%
83%
87%
Cover (# responses)
Total Score (out of 100)
Leak Prevention
Worth the Price
Trim on Baby
Fit on Baby
Liked by Skeptics
Would Recommend
Bummis Super Brite (54)
Click here to buy
82%
89%
87%
80%
78%
76%
80%
Econobum (67)
Click here to buy
79%
82%
91%
76%
79%
67%
80%
Flip (120)
Click here to buy
86%
Photobucket
87%
90%
86%
86%
79%
85%
GroVia Shell (32)
Click here to buy
86%
86%
83%
87%
91%
84%
88%
Rumparooz One Size Cover (21)
Click here to buy
80%
90%
86%
80%
76%
69%
79%
Thirsties Duo Wrap (165)
Click here to buy
88%
Photobucket
91%
91%
88%
86%
80%
89%
Thirsties Sized Covers (60)
Click here to buy
87%
Photobucket
94%
91%
84%
84%
80%
89%

Detergents

Detergent (# responses)
Overall Score (%)
% Damage (low is good)
Soft Water (%)
Hard Water (%)
Front Loader (%)
Top Loader (%)
Top Loader HE (%)
Allen's (73)
80
16
78
84
All Free and Clear (201)
60
12
74
72
81
77
Arm and Hammer Free and Clear (27)
84
6
Biokleen (36)
83
15
88
Bumgenius (70)
83
13
79
81
83
Charlie's Soap (powder) (167)
82
11
77
80
84
Country Save (201)
81
10
81
73
80
83
76
Crunchy Clean (45)
80
15
85
Dropps (20)
86
5
EcoNuts (Liquid) (22)
83
6
Eco Nuts (soap nuts) (55)
85
11
86
Ecos (30)
75
11
Ecos Free and Clear (36)
84
8
EcoSprout (117)
81
9
80
81
80
Homemade (142)
(See this article for top performing "recipes")
86
11
88
88
88
88
Laundry Tarts (36)
81
7
78
Lulu's in the Fluff (46)
87
8
87
Nellie's (70)
81
7
81
82
Purex Free and Clear (84)
85
10
83
Rockin' Green Classic (450)
79
11
80
67
78
80
79
Rockin' Green Hard (276)
78
13
79
79
79
78
Rockin' Green Soft (46)
80
9
78
80
Ruby Moon (74)
81
8
87
80
Tide (liquid) (106)
85
10
83
80
89
Tide Free (74)
83
9
85
82
88
Tide Ultra (Without Acti-Lift) (91)
90
11
92
83
93
Tiny Bubbles (75)
79
13
74
82
75

Fitted Cloth Diapers

Diaper (# responses)
Everyone
Heavy Wetter
Chunky
Chunky Thighs
Skinny
Skinny Thighs
Rash Prone
Tall
Kissaluvs Fitted (56)
Click here to buy
71
Sustainablebabyish OBF (54)
Click here to buy
88Photobucket
Thirsties Fab Fitted (77)
Click here to buy
79
Diaper (# responses)
Total (out of 100)
Absorbency
Trim on Baby
Worth the Price
Fit on Baby
Liked by Skeptics
Night (as is)
Night (not as purchased)
Would Recommend
Kissaluvs Fitted (56)
Click here to buy
71%
76%
69%
73%
79%
67%
56%
66%
74%
Sustainablebabyish OBF (54)
Click here to buy
88%
Photobucket
96%
66%
85%
86%
84%
92%
95%
88%
Thirsties Fab Fitted (77)
Click here to buy
79%
83%
75%
83%
89%
76%
61%
79%
82%

Inserts

Insert Name (# responses)
Total Score
Absorbency
Night Use
Night Use with additional insert
Stink Free After Washing
Trim
Easy to Stuff in Pocket
Flip Stay Dry (27)
Click here to buy
81
85
71
84
80
83
83
Thirsties Hemp Insert (27)
Click here to buy
93
93
94
95
92
91
92
Joey Bunz Hemp Insert (20)
Click here to buy
93
92
90
95
92
95
95

Pocket Cloth Diapers

Diaper (# responses)EveryoneHeavy Wetter ChunkyChunky ThighsSkinnySkinny ThighsRash Prone
AppleCheeks (31)
Click here to buy
72715171727179
Babykicks 3G One Size (45)
Click here to buy
72677673758163
bumGenius One Size 3.0 (30)
DISCONTINUED
77788177707081
bumGenius One Size 4.0 (188)
Click here to buy
85
Photobucket
858485848583
Bummis Tots Bots (24)
Click here to buy
79808382767180
Charlie Banana
2-in-1 Cloth Diaper System - One Size (39)
Click here to buy
82897284817787
FuzziBunz Elite One Size (117)
Click here to buy
72726772757367
FuzziBunz One Size (96)
Click here to buy
74787675737374
FuzziBunz Perfect Size (54)
Click here to buy
70737873647379
Happy Heiny's One Size (48)
Click here to buy
72727473746976
Kawaii Baby Bamboo Minky (23)
Click here to buy
87879290807982
Kawaii Baby Heavy Duty One Size (55)
Click here to buy
82808081848482
Oh Katy One Size (45)
Click here to buy
74717471747566
Rumparooz G2 One Size (101)
Click here to buy
73757474767367
Sunbaby 4.0 (34)
Click here to buy
69657272666365
Thirsties Duo (29)
Click here to buy
80866779757543
Diaper (# responses)Total (out of 100)AbsorbentFit
on
Baby
Worth
the
Price
Trim
on
Baby
Liked
by
Skeptics
Night
(as is)
Night
(not as is)
Would
Recommend
AppleCheeks (45)
Click here to buy
728578738280435880
Babykicks 3G One Size (49)
Click here to buy
728775729161586470
bumGenius One Size 3.0 (30)
DISCONTINUED
778278717887538678
bumGenius One Size 4.0 (257)
Click here to buy
85
Photobucket
9090907491678393
Bummis Tots Bots (24)
Click here to buy
798387818586516887
Charlie Banana
2-in-1 Cloth Diaper
System - One
Size (55)
Click here to buy
829187908580677287
FuzziBunz Elite One Size (135)
Click here to buy
727583828973405680
FuzziBunz One Size (107)
Click here to buy
748378777878547178
FuzziBunz Perfect Size (62)
Click here to buy
707174767776476175
Happy Heiny's One Size (48)
Click here to buy
727880787077497276
Kawaii Baby Bamboo Minky (23)
Click here to buy
878495967694678496
Kawaii Baby Heavy Duty One Size (55)
Click here to buy
828782915979829184
Oh Katy One Size (49)
Click here to buy
748182797974526081
Rumparooz G2 One Size (108)
Click here to buy
738670656575687774
Sunbaby 4.0 (34)
Click here to buy
696875837268397075
Thirsties Duo (29)
Click here to buy
809075837786658082
Blueberry Bamboo Deluxe One Size (20)809380806087708087
Kawaii Baby Snazzy Minky (22)688363893869577080

Swim Diapers

Swim Diaper (# responses)
Everyone
Heavy Wetter
Chunky
Chunky Thighs
Skinny
Skinny Thighs
Rash Prone
Tall
AppleCheeks Swim Diaper (38)


Click here to buy
97%
92%
93%
90%
88%
86%
98%
98%
Bummis Swimmi Diaper (45)


Click here to buy
92%
Photobucket
94%
95%
81%
81%
96%
97%
81%
iPlay Swim Diaper (35)
93%
92%
91%
92%
92%
94%
93%
92%
Swim Diaper (# responses)
Total
Ability to Keep in Poop
Perceived Comfort
Trim
Fit
Would Recommend
Worth the Price
Ease of Taking Off
Durability
iPlay Swim Diaper (35)
94%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
95%
78%
88%
Bummis Swimmi Diaper (45)


Click here to buy
92
Photobucket
93%
93%
87%
93%
91%
89%
98%
92%
AppleCheeks Swim Diaper (26)


Click here to buy
97%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
91%
95%
91%

Training Pants

Diaper (# responses)
Total (out of 100)
Absorbency for 1 Accident
Fit
Trim
Would Recommend
Ease of Pulling Up and Down
Worth the Price
Blueberry Training Pants (21)
Click here to buy
83%
74%
88%
87%
85%
83%
80%
Flip Potty Trainer (29)
Click here to buy
79%
79%
77%
85%
78%
77%
77%
GroVia My Choice Trainer (22)
Click here to buy
77%
80%
75%
85%
75%
74%
72%

Wet Bags and Pail Liners

Wet Bag/Pail Liner (# responses)
Total
Keeps in Stink
Traps in Wetness
Ease of Opening
Cute Designs
FuzziBunz In and Out Mess Free Hanging Diaper Bag with Zipper (33)

Click here to buy
77%
73%
85%
93%
57%
GroVia Wet Bag (27)

Click here to buy
81%
83%
96%
76%
71%
Kanga Care Wet Bag (28)

Click here to buy
91%
91%
91%
91%
89%
Kissa's Antibacterial Pail Liner (28)

Click here to buy
71%
84%
81%
89%
29%
Monkey Foot Designs Wet Bag (67)

Click here to buy
98%
Photobucket
97%
98%
98%
99%
Planet Wise Diaper Pail Liner (100)

Click here to buy
85%
Photobucket
83%
91%
97%
71%
Planet Wise Diaper Wet Bag (113)

Click here to buy
91%
Photobucket
88%
89%
90%
95%
Planet Wise Wet/Dry Diaper Wet Bag (92)

Click here to buy
92%
Photobucket
92%
94%
88%
95%